Twitter vs the Republican right.

| | Comments (5)
Although I'm on Twitter, I'm not convinced by it as a social tool - it's not even as good as Facebook status discussions, which is saying something. However, I get it for business, and I get it for campaigns. Tonight's a great example.

As Obama tries to do something about the American pay-or-die health care system, his opponents have attacked him for trying to recreate the evil socialist NHS. 

One of them went far too far and put it about that Stephen Hawking would have died if he lived in Britain. See how many problems you can spot in that one claim.

It's sparked a furious round of twittering (tweeting still sounds twee, sorry) with people posting their defence of the NHS with the hashtag #WeLoveTheNHS

You click that link, read a flurry of anecdotes, jokes and arguments for, and it tells you immediately that there have been something like "300 more results since you started searching". It's currently the third most popular topic on Twitter, and the BBC, the Telegraph and others have noticed too.

There's a backlash, obviously, with the wingnuts going hard for the socialism stuff. And in one sense they're right. The NHS is socialism in action. I've paid taxes over the last year and not been to the doctor once. When I was unemployed I went to the doctors when I needed to and didn't worry about the cost. It's from each according to his ability, to each according to her need.

It doesn't work for lattes or laptop design, neither of which are actually needs, but it's a damn fine model for health care. It's also the best thing Old Labour ever achieved, it's worth protecting, and it's time to roll back the PFI/PPP marketisation forced upon it by both New Labour and every sort of Conservative.

Question, though. If twittering about it hadn't got the mainstream media's attention, how much impact would this have had on the American campaign? Right now, given the way journalists love techo-novelty, I think it'll help. US media will surely cover it, and they'll have plenty of short quotable stories about the merits of living somewhere where you don't have to feel for your wallet before the doctors feel for a pulse. 


very good post. oh how we laughed at the republican woman on the web tranny yesterday morning screaming that she didn't want her country going the way of socialist Russia - chilling

No the NHS is Liberalim in action, with socialist rhetoric. When first proposed it was described by a left wing Labour MP as a 'Liberal social-ambulance service'- Sir William Beveridge was a Liberal. What Obama is proposing is more akin to David Lloyd George's National Health Insurance Act 1911 than the NHS.

Ps Barry Wood has left the Greens and rejoined the Liberal Democrats.

"they'll have plenty of short quotable stories about the merits of living somewhere where you don't have to feel for your wallet before the doctors feel for a pulse."

I've always loved that particular lie. It's so obviously bunk (medicare, medicaid, free clinics) yet the left repeats it ad verbatim in order to protect the only vaguely good thing Liarbore have ever done in the last...well, ever.

Socialism. Sometimes it...never works.

Also, Beveridge was a Liberal, sure, but Attlee wasn't. As a Green I'm happy to see good ideas wherever they're from. However, in this case I can't see the NHS as anything but socialist, given the to each, from each, nature of it as set out above.

Obama's plan looks to me like a much weaker version of the NHS, sadly.

Leave a comment

Your Links At Last


Other Politics



Friends and Stuff I Like

If I've forgotten to link to you, let me know. If I don't want to link to your blog I'll pretend I never got your email.

The party's site of which I am rather proud

Along with Jeff (formerly SNP Tactical Voting) and Malc (formerly In The Burgh), I now co-edit Better Nation, a group blog. Stuff will still appear here, but more will be there. Better Nation

Post History

This page was published on August 12, 2009 9:55 PM.

When two tribes go into coalition. was the previous entry in this blog.

Newspapers going through the five stages of grief. is the next entry in this blog.